Compare · Figures checked September 2026
Compare Spark accelerators side by side
ETL Compare staff · Published 29 September 2026
In brief
Choose two to five accelerators to see every ETL fit criterion, the reason behind each score, where each runs and what each publishes about price. The default view shows the three highest-ranked products on our lead ranking: Apache Gluten, DualBird and DataFusion Comet. Head-to-head pages for all 36 pairs and an alternatives page for each product are listed below the table.
| Gluten + Velox | DualBird | Comet | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overview | |||
| Rank | Rank 1 of 9 | Rank 2 of 9 | Rank 3 of 9 |
| ETL fit score | 3.73 / 5 ETL fit score (editorial assessment, 0-5) | 3.72 / 5 ETL fit score (editorial assessment, 0-5) | 3.67 / 5 ETL fit score (editorial assessment, 0-5) |
| Best for | Open-source native engine for self-managed Spark | Best for spill- and shuffle-heavy ETL on EMR and EKS | Best for teams on recent Spark 4.x releases |
| Approach | Open-source plugin that offloads Spark SQL execution to a native C++ engine (Velox or ClickHouse) | Commercial Spark plugin paired with Amazon EC2 F2 instances, aimed at spill, skew and shuffle bottlenecks | Open-source Spark plugin that runs supported operators on the Apache DataFusion engine (Rust, Arrow) |
| Criterion scores | |||
| Adoption effort 20% | 3.8No application code changes; you add the Gluten JAR, set spark.plugins, enable off-heap memory and switch the shuffle manager, per the Velox getting-started page. | 4.6Highest in selectionDualBird states two steps: change the EC2 instance type and add the DualBird Spark plugin, with no code changes and no platform move for EMR and EKS users. | 3.8No code changes; add the Comet jar from Maven Central, enable the extension and configure off-heap memory and the Comet shuffle manager. |
| Stage coverage 20% | 3.8Offloads execution to the Velox native engine with a columnar shuffle manager; spilling is documented as experimental. | 4.8Highest in selectionThe only vendor in this set whose product page names all three ETL pain points directly: disk spills, data skew and shuffle data, plus an end-to-end claim. | 3.6Native Parquet scans (including for Iceberg), native operators and native or columnar shuffle; native operators can spill, bounded per task; write path not described on the pages we reviewed. |
| Tuning and operating burden 20% | 2.6You size off-heap memory yourself (the docs example uses 20g) and rely on community channels; no vendor support contract is described on the project pages. | 4.4Highest in selectionDualBird states "no more performance tuning and troubleshooting" and the product is vendor-supported; this is a vendor claim we could not check. | 2.8The tuning guide says memory accounting "isn't 100% accurate" and describes pool fractions, batch size and spill limits to set; community support. |
| Platform and instance portability 10% | 4.3Highest in selectionSupports Spark 3.4, 3.5, 4.0 and 4.1 on x86_64 and aarch64 Linux on standard CPU instances; managed-platform guides are not listed, so you install it yourself. | 2.4Documented for Apache Spark, Amazon EMR and Amazon EKS on AWS only, and it runs on Amazon EC2 F2 instances rather than the instance types most jobs use today. | 4.2Supports Spark 3.5, 4.0 and 4.1 (3.4 deprecated) with prebuilt Linux amd64 and arm64 jars on commodity hardware; you install it yourself on any platform. |
| Cost model transparency 5% | 5.0Tied highest in selectionApache License 2.0, no license fee; cost is your existing compute plus engineering time. | 2.0No pricing on the pages we reviewed; buyers need a quote to compare the fee plus F2 instance cost against current spend. | 5.0Tied highest in selectionApache License 2.0, no license fee. |
| Published evidence 15% | 3.8Tied highest in selectionPublishes TPC-H and TPC-DS results (Velox backend 2.71x overall, tested June 2023) with the benchmark named; results come from the project. | 2.8Publishes an Iceberg compaction benchmark with dataset shape and cost per TB, written by DualBird staff; cluster sizes and Spark versions are not stated and no third-party results were found. | 3.8Tied highest in selectionPublishes a TPC-DS at 1 TB benchmark with a per-query breakdown in its Benchmarking Guide. |
| Maturity and community 10% | 4.4Highest in selectionApache top-level project since March 2026, started by Intel and Kyligence in 2022, with contributors including Alibaba Cloud, Meituan, Microsoft, IBM and Google. | 2.0A young commercial product (it raised $25M in February 2026) with a short public track record and no open-source community. | 3.9A subproject of Apache DataFusion that has reached a 1.x release line; younger than Gluten and RAPIDS. |
| Where it runs | |||
| Runs on | Self-managed Spark 3.4 to 4.1 on Linux, on any platform where you control Spark config | Apache Spark, Amazon EMR and Amazon EKS, on AWS | Self-managed Spark 3.5, 4.0 and 4.1 (3.4 deprecated) on Linux |
| Instances | Standard CPU instances (x86_64 or aarch64) | Amazon EC2 F2 instances | Commodity CPU instances (amd64 or arm64) |
| EMR | Not documentedself-install | Documented | Not documentedself-install |
| Databricks | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Google Cloud (Dataproc) | Not documentedself-install | Not documentedAWS only | Not documentedself-install |
| AWS Glue | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Self-managed Spark / Kubernetes | Documented | DocumentedApache Spark, Amazon EKS | Documented |
| Price and license | |||
| License | Apache License 2.0 | Commercial | Apache License 2.0 |
| Published price | No license fee | Not published; contact DualBird | No license fee |
| Code changes | None; JAR plus Spark configuration | None stated; change instance type and add plugin | None; jar plus Spark configuration |
| Stage coverage | |||
| Read | Partial | Partial | Documented |
| Transform | Documented | Documented | Documented |
| Shuffle | Documented | Documented | Documented |
| Spill | Partial | Documented | Partial |
| Write | Not stated | Partial | Not stated |
Sources: gluten.apache.org, Velox backend getting started, apache/gluten on GitHub, dualbird.io, DualBird product page, Iceberg compaction benchmark, A Simpler Spark, datafusion.apache.org/comet, Comet installation guide, Comet tuning guide · Fetched 27 Sep 2026
Which head-to-head comparisons are there?
Apache Auron vs DataFusion Comet
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 3.42).
Apache Auron vs DataPelago
Apache Auron has the higher ETL fit score (3.42 against 3.14).
Apache Auron vs DualBird
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.42).
Apache Auron vs Flarion
Apache Auron has the higher ETL fit score (3.42 against 3.15).
Apache Auron vs Apache Gluten
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.42).
Apache Auron vs Databricks Photon
Databricks Photon has the higher ETL fit score (3.46 against 3.42).
Apache Auron vs RAPIDS Accelerator
RAPIDS Accelerator has the higher ETL fit score (3.65 against 3.42).
Apache Auron vs Speedata
Apache Auron has the higher ETL fit score (3.42 against 2.61).
DataFusion Comet vs DataPelago
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 3.14).
DataFusion Comet vs Flarion
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 3.15).
DataFusion Comet vs Databricks Photon
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 3.46).
DataFusion Comet vs RAPIDS Accelerator
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 3.65).
DataFusion Comet vs Speedata
DataFusion Comet has the higher ETL fit score (3.67 against 2.61).
DataPelago vs DualBird
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.14).
DataPelago vs Flarion
Flarion has the higher ETL fit score (3.15 against 3.14).
DataPelago vs Apache Gluten
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.14).
DataPelago vs Databricks Photon
Databricks Photon has the higher ETL fit score (3.46 against 3.14).
DataPelago vs RAPIDS Accelerator
RAPIDS Accelerator has the higher ETL fit score (3.65 against 3.14).
DataPelago vs Speedata
DataPelago has the higher ETL fit score (3.14 against 2.61).
DualBird vs DataFusion Comet
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.67).
DualBird vs Flarion
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.15).
DualBird vs Apache Gluten
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.72).
DualBird vs Databricks Photon
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.46).
DualBird vs RAPIDS Accelerator
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 3.65).
DualBird vs Speedata
DualBird has the higher ETL fit score (3.72 against 2.61).
Flarion vs Apache Gluten
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.15).
Flarion vs Databricks Photon
Databricks Photon has the higher ETL fit score (3.46 against 3.15).
Flarion vs RAPIDS Accelerator
RAPIDS Accelerator has the higher ETL fit score (3.65 against 3.15).
Flarion vs Speedata
Flarion has the higher ETL fit score (3.15 against 2.61).
Apache Gluten vs DataFusion Comet
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.67).
Apache Gluten vs Databricks Photon
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.46).
Apache Gluten vs RAPIDS Accelerator
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 3.65).
Apache Gluten vs Speedata
Apache Gluten has the higher ETL fit score (3.73 against 2.61).
Databricks Photon vs RAPIDS Accelerator
RAPIDS Accelerator has the higher ETL fit score (3.65 against 3.46).
Databricks Photon vs Speedata
Databricks Photon has the higher ETL fit score (3.46 against 2.61).
RAPIDS Accelerator vs Speedata
RAPIDS Accelerator has the higher ETL fit score (3.65 against 2.61).
Which products have an alternatives page?
How should you read this table?
Scores are editorial assessments on a 0 to 5 scale against the criteria on the method page. The marker in each criterion row shows the highest score among the products you selected, and shared highs are shown as ties. Platform and price rows repeat what each vendor or project publishes; "Not documented" means we did not find the platform on the pages we reviewed, not that the product cannot run there. To apply your own weights, use the calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How many products can I compare at once?
Two to five. Your selection is kept in the page address, so you can bookmark or share it.
Why is Amazon EMR not in the list?
Amazon EMR is a platform that runs Spark, not an accelerator, so it is not scored. The table shows which products are documented for EMR and the other platforms, and several run on EMR. See where Spark accelerators run.
Where do the scores come from?
From desk research on public vendor and project pages, scored against seven weighted criteria. See how we score. We did not run the products.